A federal judge has issued a partial ruling on the legal challenge to New York City’s congestion pricing plan, which would charge drivers entering Manhattan. U.S. District Court Judge Leo M. Gordon ruled that New York has taken most of the necessary steps to implement the program, but requested further information from the Federal Highway Administration FHWA regarding certain aspects of the program.
Despite this, the judge did not make a definitive statement on whether the program should proceed as scheduled for January 5, 2025.
Governor Kathy Hochul and Metropolitan Transportation Authority MTA Chair Janno Lieber expressed confidence that the plan will proceed, with Lieber emphasizing the court’s agreement on most issues.
However, New Jersey’s attorney, Randy Mastro, argued that the decision effectively puts the program on hold until further clarification from federal officials.
Mastro pointed to the judge’s concerns over the FHWA’s approval process and its lack of a rational explanation for the tolling scheme changes. The FHWA has until January 17, 2025, to provide additional feedback.
The legal battle continues, with New Jersey opposing the toll system and its potential impact on commuters entering Manhattan.