It didn’t come as a surprise to many Black New Yorkers that Mayor Eric Adams has been rallying support from African American civil rights leaders, clergy, and grassroots activists following his recent indictment on federal bribery charges.
Adams, a Brooklyn native who worked his way up from the city’s working class to its highest political office, is viewed by many as more than just New York’s second Black mayor. To many in the community, he’s like family.
“Four more years!” chanted a group of Black clergy who gathered outside City Hall to pray for Adams earlier this week.
Please continue to lift me and this administration up in prayer for the strength to keep moving forward, Adams told them. He reminded the group of the struggles they shared during his campaign: This is what we fought for, and many of you were a part of that.
However, even the closest families face challenges. Adams’ five-count indictment has led to calls for his resignation from Black activists, politicians, and residents. It has also sparked debates over whether to stand by a controversial figure who represents a historic moment for Black political representation.
Adams’ situation echoes similar moments in Black political history—when a community member rises to power, faces legal trouble, and looks to the voters for support.
Two years ago, New Yorkers elected a record number of Black leaders to local and state offices. Now, some fear that Adams’ legal troubles could cast a shadow over this progress. There is a delicate balance between holding leaders accountable while ensuring the preservation of Black political power.
As we gain power, we must use it to protect the people who helped us get there, said Rev. Al Sharpton, head of the National Action Network. But we also shouldn’t be quick to condemn because of accusations. Sharpton, who has known Adams for over 35 years, told the Associated Press that he’s never known Adams to engage in criminal behavior.
Federal prosecutors allege that Adams accepted illegal campaign contributions and luxury travel perks from Turkish officials in exchange for political favors, including fast-tracking the opening of a Turkish consulate building in Manhattan despite fire safety concerns.
Adams’ administration has also been the subject of several investigations, including probes into the actions of his former police commissioner, his deputy mayor, and close adviser Tim Pearson—all of whom have denied any wrongdoing. Pearson stepped down recently, following other high-profile resignations.
The indictment is being led by U.S. Attorney Damian Williams, who is also Black. Some Black leaders, like former New York Assemblyman Michael Blake, view Adams’ indictment as a pivotal moment for Black communities. This can’t be the standard, Blake said, noting the chaos and embarrassment the situation has caused. He added that he doesn’t expect Adams to still be in office by 2026.
The question of whether Adams should resign has sparked mixed reactions among Black leaders. Sharpton plans to consult other prominent Black officials in New York before making any decisions. We need to talk, Sharpton said. We may feel he’s innocent but can’t run the city, or we may feel he’s guilty. We don’t know yet.
Meanwhile, some leaders have already voiced concerns. New York City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams, who shares no relation to the mayor, urged him to consider whether he can effectively lead the city during this legal battle. Each New Yorker deserves a mayor who upholds the dignity and integrity this office requires, added New York State Senator Zellnor Myrie.
Despite the pressure, Adams has strong defenders. Brooklyn Assemblywoman Rodneyse Bichotte Hermelyn questioned the timing and fairness of the charges, reminding people that an indictment isn’t a conviction. She emphasized that Adams’ broad support comes from diverse and working-class communities of color.
Adams himself remains defiant, pointing to messages of support he has received. Eric, stay the course, he said, quoting words of encouragement from his supporters.
As the city watches the legal process unfold, the future of Eric Adams’ leadership—and his impact on Black political representation—hangs in the balance.